This post may contain compensated links, please read our disclaimer for more info.
A BCD is an important part of your scuba gear. Also known as a buoyancy control device, a buoyancy control compensator (BCC) or simply buoyancy compensator (BC), this vital piece of your diving equipment controls your descent and ascent. It also helps you to maintain your position in the water during your dive. But, what is the best BCD? This detailed guide has all the information you need to choose the best BCD for you.
There are many different types of BCDs available. To be as comfortable as possible during your dive, you have to choose the best BCD for you. This might or might not be the best BCD on the market today or the one with the most features. There’s a BCD for (almost) every size and every budget. I use a pretty basic Mares BCD myself. So far I’ve done 500+ dives with this BC and I’m still happy with it. So, please keep in mind that the best scuba gear is not necessarily the most expensive. It’s just what fits you and your budget best.
- 1 Best BCD comparison table
- 2 How to choose your BCD
- 3 BCD maintenance
- 4 2018 BCD reviews
- 5 Best travel BCD
- 6 Best back inflate BCD
- 7 Best tech BCD for travel
Best BCD comparison table
How to choose your BCD
There are so many options, how do you know which BCD to choose? My partner had the same question a while ago and did hours of online research. That’s why we decided to create this Best BCD Buying Guide. So you have all the information you need to make an informed decision about which BCD you want to buy. Scuba BC’s are available from all the best scuba gear brands. The best BCD for diving is different for everyone. What you’re looking for is the best buoyancy compensator for you. We’ll discuss the major BCD features you need to pay attention to, the best BCD brands and give you scuba BCD reviews of the best BCD for beginners, the best budget BCD, the best BCD for travel, the best BCD for women, the best tech BCD and many more.
Size of your BCD
Nothing is as uncomfortable as a BCD that doesn’t fit. You have to keep pushing it down, you can’t reach your dump valves or your weights when you have to dump them, or the straps slide off your shoulders even at their shortest. So, make sure to choose a buoyancy compensator that fits your body type. Regular BC’s are one size fits all and gender neutral, but nowadays there are also female fit BCD’s. The ‘female’ part about them is not that they are all pink or purple (although you can find those too if you want), but that they have a shorter back and narrower shoulder straps that curve away from the chest.
Jacket style BCDThe scuba diving vest or scuba diving jacket BCD is the most used BCD style. It’s the preferred type of BCD for a lot of recreational divers, both beginners and advanced. The wrap around air bladder provides both great vertical surface stability as well as horizontal stability while diving, making it the obvious choice for teaching purposes. There are two types of BCD jackets, with or without integrated weights. Jacket style BCD’s are available in a wide range of prices, from our best budget choice BCD, the Cressi Start to our much more advanced best jacket style BCD choice Aqua Lung Axiom i3.
Back inflate BCD / Wing BCDWhen diving a good horizontal positioning in the water is important. The more horizontal, the more streamlined you are which minimizes workload and energy. A backplate and wing BCD has the air bladder positioned on the back, behind the diver. In a way the diver is suspended or hanging in the harness, secured by a velcro cummerbund. As opposed to a jacket BCD, which has air all around, the front of the wing style BCD is completely flat. This makes it less cluttered and allows for easier arm movements. Wing bcd diving takes a bit of practice. The back inflate vs jacket bcd difference is most noticeable on the surface. Because you have no air bladder on the front and sides, the bladder in the back pushes you face forward and makes it a bit more difficult to stay vertically upright. Our choices for the best wing BCD or best back inflate BCD are the Zeagle Ranger BCD and the Scubapro Knighthawk.
Hybrid BCDIf you want the horizontal stability that a wing BCD provides, without having to struggle to stay upright when kneeling down on the bottom or while on the surface, a hybrid BCD is for you. It combines the best of the jacket BCD and the wing BCD in one. Hybrid BCD reviews are very positive about this innovative design. It has the comfort of a jacket BCD with the energy efficiency of a back inflate BCD. The Mares Hybrid is our choice for the best hybrid BCD. It has great fit and can fold small enough to fit in a travel bag.
Travel BCDTraveling light definitely has our preference. Anyone else hate hauling around heavy bags? Unfortunately diving equipment can be quite bulky. So it was only a matter of time before someone invented a travel BCD. Lightweight AquaLung Zuma (only 4.75 lbs or 2.2kg for size M/L) was one of the first bcd’s for travel a few years ago. But nowadays most scuba brands offer a lightweight travel BCD model. Basically, a travel BCD is not a BCD style in itself. It can be any of the above mentioned BCD types, jacket, wing, hybrid or tech BCD.
- ScubaPro travel BCD
- AquaLung travel BCD
- Cressi travel BCD
- Mares travel BCD
- Zeagle travel BCD
- Sherwood travel BCD
- Oceanic travel BCD
The main factors deciding if a BCD is suitable for travel are weight and packing size. The best travel BCD really depends on your travel style. Obviously you’ll want an extremely lightweight and small version when backpacking and just want a BCD that fits in your dive luggage when you’re going on a dedicated dive trip of live aboard. A BCD that’s limited in weight and dimensions simply has to compromise on comfort and durability. So when deciding on the best BCD for travel, make sure to pay close attention to the travel BCD reviews.
Backplate and wing BCD / Tech BCDA technical diving BCD is also called a backplate and wing BCD. It’s used by divers who are into advanced diving, such as technical deep diving, cave diving or wreck penetration. Don’t confuse them with the back inflation or wing BCD mentioned above, they are vastly different. Backplate BCD’s for technical diving consist of 3 separate components: a backplate, a wing or air bladder and a harness. A tech dive BCD is modular and very versatile. An infinite number of combinations of backplate, wing, harness and harness hardware is possible. This makes it possible to adapt and assemble the BCD to meet your diving needs. So again, the best tech BCD is the usually a custom set up. A special sub style of the technical diving BCD is the sidemount BCD, which originates from cave diving, but is becoming more popular among tech divers. Some of the best tech diving BCD brands are Zeagle, Hollis, Apeks and Dive Rite.
Lift capacity of your BC
In general, the lift capacity of a BCD increases with its size and is enough to support a person of average weight with a single tank. If you’re quite large or heavy, or dive with multiple tanks, lift capacity is something to take into consideration when choosing a new scuba BCD. We have added this factor to our comparison table.
BCD weight integration
If you’re diving in tropical waters, in a shorty or even just a board short, you don’t need that many weights and it’s not much of an issue to wear a weight belt. But if you need more weights, having them all on your hips can be uncomfortable. Even more so if you have back problems. Integrated weights are a great invention. The strategically placed weight pockets are attached to your BCD, which helps you with positioning in the water. And it’s one less accessory you have to keep track of. The weight pockets have a quick release system, making it easy to dump them if necessary. Make sure to attach them properly, because they’re also easy to lose! Some BCD’s also offer trim pockets to secure additional weights at the back of the BCD or on the tank straps.
AIR or alternate air source BCD
The basic set up for scuba gear is a regulator set with a primary regulator (also called primary second stage) and an alternate air source (octopus), combined with a BCD to regulate buoyancy. The traditional BCD has an over the left shoulder inflator/deflator hose. An alternative to this is to use an AIR or alternate inflator regulator, such as the Scubapro Air2, the Oceanic Air XS2 or the Mares Air Control octopus inflator. With an AIR the alternate air source is integrated in the inflator hose, it’s a combined inflator with alternate regulator. In case of an emergency OOA (out of air) situation you give your primary regulator to your buddy and use the regulator that’s integrated in your inflator hose. So what are the Air2 pros and cons?
- no octopus, so one less hose and less clutter
- no issue with storing your octopus so it doesn’t drag
- your alternate or breathable power inflator is always in the same place and close
- less weight (one less hose and octopus), so travel-friendly
- can’t easily switch to another BCD because your reg set has no octopus and your inflator connection doesn’t fit
- can’t easily switch regulators, because the Air2 has a non-standard port for attaching your regulator hose
- different OOA emergency procedure than most divers are used to
- ascend with your buoyancy device in your mouth
- you need to remember to service it, just like any other octopus
Of course, whichever set up you choose, you always need to train to familiarise yourself with it. This is especially true in case of an integrated octopus inflator. This alternate air source BCD is becoming more popular and as with all innovations, there are always people who love it and people who hate it.
BCD pockets & D-rings
If you bring a lot of additional equipment while diving, you need to pay attention to the availability of pockets and D-rings on your new buoyancy device. A dive light, surface marker, clip for your octopus, underwater camera, slate, back up mask or straps… even if you don’t bring an excessive amount of tools and scuba accessories you quickly run out of rings and pockets to secure them. While you can add additional attachment points, it’s much easier if your BCD of choice has them out of the box. If you’re planning to carry heavy equipment make sure the D-rings are stainless steel and not plastic. Travel BCD’s will generally have plastic D-rings as they are lighter. As for pockets, I definitely prefer pockets with a zipper instead of a velcro closing.
As with all scuba equipment, a BCD can be quite an investment. But if you take good care of it, it will last a good few years. Rinse your BCD well with fresh water after each dive and use BCD cleaner & conditioner to keep your BCD in good condition.
2018 BCD reviews
It can be hard work to compare BCD’s, so we’ve made a selection of the best BCD’s on the market. For each of our categories, we’ve chosen the best option for you. Check below for the best travel BCD, the best budget BCD, the best jacket style BCD, the best tech BCD, the best back inflation BCD, the best hybrid BCD and the best women’s BCD.
Best travel BCD
Cressi Travelight BCD reviewAt 5 to 6.2lbs (2.3 to 2.8kg) this Cressi travel BCD is a travel BCD in the true sense of the word. It’s extremely lightweight but more importantly, it’s also very functional and durable as. The flexible backplate allows for this Cressi buoyancy compensator to be rolled up in a small package. Two tank straps secure the cylinder and make sure the back is sufficiently rigid. A wide cummerbund, good back padding and adjustable shoulder, waist and chest straps ensure comfortable diving.
For this Cressi BCD a lot of research was done and the best lightweight materials were chosen. The 210 denier nylon is light, but very strong. The D rings are made of a lightweight but strong alloy, and with 10 of them there is plenty of space for your dive tools. The Cressi Travel Light has two large zippered pockets to store even more of your equipment. Providing from 13.5 to 36 lbs. (6.1 to 16.3 kg) of lift, depending on size, this lightweight travel BCD is perfect for tropical diving. It even comes with the integrated Lock Aid weight system. The Cressi Travelight is available in multiple colors.
Best back inflate BCD
Scubapro Knighthawk reviewThe Scubapro Knighthawk BCD has been a stable part of the ScubaPro collection for a number of years. Where other models come and go, the sturdy and trusted Knighhawk BC has remained. Of course, it’s has seen a number of improvements over the years. Many serious recreational divers use this back inflate BCD and love it, as a huge number of raving Knighthawk BCD reviews prove.
The Knighthawk’s air bladder is positioned behind the diver, which eliminates clutter on the front and allows maximum freedom of movement. The retractable air cell minimizes the drag considerably. Four stainless steel D rings offer you plenty of space to store your gear. Quick release integrated weight pockets offer additional comfort and are counterbalanced by two rear trim pockets.
Made of rugged 1000 denier nylon with welded seams the Scubapro Knighthawk BC is a durable, quality BC that will last for years to come. It has a backpack style harness system with a comfortable padded backpad and a cushioned neck roll. Standard this back inflation BCD comes with a balanced power inflator, but the Knighthawk BCD with AIR 2 is also available. The Scubapro Knighthawk AIR 2 has a slightly higher price tag.
The Scuba Pro Knighthawk was designed specifically for men, with a low profile back harness. For women, ScubaPro has designed the ScubaPro Ladyhawk.
Best tech BCD for travel
Zeagle Express Tech Deluxe reviewThe Zeagle Express Tech Deluxe BCD is a modular tech BCD meant for travel. It weighs only 6.5lbs (2,95kg) and folds small enough to fit in a backpack or suitcase. The Express Tech Deluxe has a flexible and light polymer reinforced backplate and a compact 24lbs retractable bladder.
Because of its modular setup with separate backplate, bladder, and harness it can be configured and adapted to the diver’s needs, even as they evolve. Novice divers might fight the ‘tech’ feel of this BCD a bit intimidating, but it’s suitable for divers of all level and both for recreational and tech diving. The backplate allows for the attachment of twin tanks. Read our full review of the Zeagle Express Tech Deluxe BCD >>
Amazon Disclosure ScubaAroundTheWorld.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.ca, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.de, Amazon.fr, Amazon.se, Amazon.it and affiliated sites.